Bushwacker Cake (Photos courtesy of Rum Sisters)

Bushwacker Cake (Photos courtesy of Rum Sisters)

"We got chills...the fact that our cake touched all of these people."—Elizabeth Jones and Kelly O-Sullivan, Co-Founders/Owners


(Gulf Shores, Alabama)

Kelly O'Sullivan and Elizabeth Jones, founders of Rum Sisters.

Kelly O'Sullivan and Elizabeth Jones, founders of Rum Sisters.

Business Start Date: Rum Sisters opened on November 11, 2014.
Describe Your Business: Rum Sisters is a gourmet bakery specializing in alcohol-infused cakes. The bakery is a retail, wholesale, and online business.
What Are You Best Known For: The Bushwacker Rum Cake is our number one seller. Running a close second now is our Island Time Rum Cake (introduced in late April 2016). During the winter months our Spice It Up! Rum Cake is very popular.
Top 3 Business Statistics or Milestones:
- Getting our packaging/shipping nailed down before Thanksgiving 2014 (which was only two weeks after opening).
- We shipped more than 500 cakes (out of 1,200 baked) during the 2014–15 holiday season! (We had only been open for a month and half.) During the 2015–16 holiday season, we shipped 2,300 cakes (out of 6,000 baked).
- We hit more than 1,000 likes on Facebook after being open for only a few months.
What’s Your “Secret Sauce”? (Why/How have you achieved success?)
We have stayed focused on working as a team and on delivering a superior product with exceptional customer service.


What event, experience, or collection of events/experiences compelled you to pursue this business?
ELIZABETH JONES: In July 2014, the aviation business my husband and I run was a sponsor of the Blue Marlin Grand Championship fishing [tournament] here in Gulf Shores, Alabama. As a sponsor, we wanted to provide a memorable [promotional] gift for these high-end clients. Discussing this with Kelly [who has been a longtime friend], we decided to make rum cakes, based on a recipe from my mom Linda Shay. We baked 75 rum cakes in 2 days. When people saw them and tasted them they said, ”Where did you get these? Where can we buy them?” We couldn’t believe the response.
KELLY O’SULLIVAN: We share a love for food. We also started drinking together 25 years ago! We’ve been like sisters since the [beginning]…[With the cakes,] we felt like we were on to something.

Did you have any experience starting or running a similar business? What kind of training did you do to prepare?
ELIZABETH: We both have been in business but never started something. I’m involved in my husband’s [aviation] business, and I had thought of having something of my own, though I didn’t know what it would be.
KELLY: Elizabeth is a great cook. I like to bake. But we had no formal training.
We took courses in food handling and safe food processing.

What was your first step toward making the business a reality?
KELLY: After the event, we kept getting calls about the cakes. We wondered: Is there viability in alcoholic baked goods? (Or, are we just drinking too much…?)
     We decided to take some samples to Chef Chris Sherrill, an award-winning chef, at the Flora-Bama Yacht Club for his feedback. He liked them enough to say, “Let’s do some for the Kenny Chesney concert coming up [the Flora-Bama-Jama in August 2014] and use his Blue Chair Bay rum. Within 24 hours, we had created a Bushwacker cake and a gluten-free Bushwacker cake. [Bushwacker is a spiked frozen milkshake drink of the Alabama coast that includes rum, chocolate, coffee, and coconut flavors.] Chris tried them and said, “Oh my God. This is it!” He put them on the menu during the free concert, which had 40,000 attendees and took place on the beach in front of the [club/restaurant]. We sold most of the 50 large cakes, served by the slice, the weekend of the concert.

What was the initial development period like?
ELIZABETH: When the cakes were a success at the restaurant, we created an LLC that same month—Rum Sisters. From there we were very lucky; we found a bakery that was going out of business three months after opening. We signed the lease on October 1, 2014, and opened on November 11, 2014.
     It was as if everything had lined up for us—finding the bakery space, in particular. We’re in an area that is usually busy in summer months and quiet in the winter; here we had a product for holiday business.
     We did no advertising. We sent emails to friends and family, and fishing groups—about a couple hundred people. Word of mouth was our biggest publicity. We started with four or five types of cakes. We sold in stores and shipped them. For the November to December period in 2014, we baked 1,200 cakes, 500 of which were shipped. [For the following year, for that same holiday period, they baked 6,000 cakes and shipped 2,300.]

When was the first glimmer that you were on to something?
KELLY: When we heard the feedback. People tasting our cakes for the first time would say, “Oh my God!” It’s an experience; people have memories associated with the cakes.
ELIZABETH: Really by the end of the first week, we were seeing a very positive reception by the local community.

How did you monetize your work? What was or became your financial strategy?
KELLY: This was self-funded. We had really low start-up costs.
     We created one-year and five-year business plans. We fell short on some of the first numbers, but we adjusted the plans. In the first year of business, we didn’t take salaries. We were able to increase our revenue and cut costs after being in business for a year. We were certainly able to leverage our buying power to reduce the cost of goods sold (cogs) as well as increase revenue through social media [marketing].

Do you have a mentor or consulting team?
ELIZABETH: Kel Jones, my husband. He’s supported us and has been a cheerleader and mentor. I get excited about a new idea for the business, and he will sometimes remind me, “That’s not your focus.”
KELLY: Elizabeth and Kel. We’re like the Three Musketeers (or the Three Stooges…!) It’s a family support system.

What is the best advice someone has given you?
KELLY: Trust your gut instinct. Don’t let people talk you into something you’re not ready to do.
ELIZABETH: You’ve got a great product. Focus on your infrastructure. [That means] standardize your procedures to ensure quality. Ask yourself: Is the foundation strong enough for growth? We’ve had offers and have had to think about this before shifting focus to things like another store, franchising, or bringing in investors.

What has been your company’s best moment so far?
KELLY: The stories we hear are the best moments. Our favorite: A local woman came in a week after she bought a cake and told us that she gave some to her 90-year-old grandmother who has Alzheimer’s. No one had talked with her in years. She ate some of the rum cake, and the woman told us, “Memories were pouring out of her. She had moments of clarity. There were stories and tears from the whole family who was there.” We got chills—the fact that our cake touched all of these people.

What has been your company’s worst moment so far?
ELIZABETH: No one thing, but financial decisions we made—too early—that were not necessarily the best—in marketing, technology, and SEO. My advice would be for any food business getting started and thinking of being online driven to [consider] very seriously the choices you make for the website platform and online store options, and make sure you have great technology people to get your SEO in the right direction at the start.

What’s easier than you thought it would be?
KELLY: Coming up with new cakes. It’s been like magic. When we needed to come up with a new cake, we got it each time the first time we tried. Except for one—key lime. The flavors, [key lime and rum] just didn’t mesh.
ELIZABETH: Keeping up the pace day in, day out. Staying inspired, because we’re passionate about what we do.

What’s harder than you thought it would be?
ELIZABETH: I didn’t understand what was needed to set up an online business.
KELLY: Time management. Although we have two part-time people helping, it’s mostly still just the two of us running the business.

What has been the funniest/weirdest thing that has happened so far?
KELLY: We ship cakes for a lot of clients, and we were asked to ship a sampler package to Alaska. We couldn’t stop laughing when we read an email we got from a recipient that said:

Dear Rum Sisters....A lady named Emma sent my wife Cindy some of your product for her birthday tomorrow. I regret to inform you that the rocket scientist driving the UPS truck left the package on our doorstep. You will be happy to know that the neighborhood bear thoroughly enjoyed a satsuma, an original, a banana-bourbon, and a Bushwacker rum cake, but alas my wife did not. I have called [the delivery service] and explained that in Alaska it should be policy not to abandon food on the doorstep lest Yogi bear, or one of our other wild creatures will make a buffet out of it. They said they would be contacting you to remedy the problem. Thanks for trying. We anxiously await the rum cake. The wrappers smelled delicious.

Is there a quote, mantra, book, or something else that motivates you?
ELIZABETH: A quote: “You get what you give.” If I’m giving a smile and great service, it’s going to come back to me.
KELLY: A quote: “Failure is not an option.” We started over. This is everything we have.

What do you hope to achieve from this point forward?
ELIZABETH: We want to increase online sales, and open stores in major cities. We’re building a brand. We’re also starting a charity called Support a Sister. We’re moms first—we each have two boys—and we want to help women who have fallen on hard times.[]

[This profile was edited for clarity.]